Graham Bennett, Lerners LLP (Kitchener)
Ontario’s workers’ compensation system rests on an old bargain. Injured workers receive no-fault benefits and, in exchange, give up the right to sue. So when an injured person starts a lawsuit, the defendants may ask the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal to rule that the right of action has been taken away.
Earlier this month, the Tribunal released Decision No. 350/26, 2026 ONWSIAT 1317. I appeared at the two-day hearing with my Lerners colleagues Sandev Purewal and Alec Yarascavitch, on behalf of a young client who was catastrophically injured while repairing a privately owned vehicle under an informal, one-time barter. The Tribunal dismissed the application and found that his right to sue is not taken away.
Three points from the reasons may be of wider interest:
- Timing matters. Status is assessed at the time of the accident. Brief working arrangements that had already ended did not carry forward.
- Location is not the whole answer. The repair took place outside a business premises, but it was personal in nature and outside the industry of the businesses involved.
- Different statutes ask different questions. The definitions in the Occupational Health and Safety Act and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997 overlap, but a finding under one does not decide the other.
For anyone hurt while doing a favour, an odd job or a trade of services, the label “worker” is not applied automatically. It depends on the facts, and the facts deserve a careful look before anyone assumes a lawsuit is off the table.
The decision remains open to reconsideration and judicial review. As always, past results are not necessarily indicative of future results, and outcomes vary with the facts of each case.
